THERE’S NOTHING STUPID OR SILLY ABOUT THE GAMAL, JUST A DARK WITTY IRISH NOVEL BY TALENTED NEW WRITER

Standard

The_Gamal_MMP_lower_resOne of the many scourges of society these days, if not the most harrowing, is suicide. It often leaves more questions than answers and despite being seen by some as the cowards way out or a desperate call for help, deep down you know at the heart is a poor soul who just can’t see any solution to their troubles, no matter how much help they get.

Ireland has one of the highest rates of suicide in the European Union, 554 were recorded in 2011 alone, according to the Central Statistics Office.  It is especially prevalent among young men, who are five times more likely to take their own life.  In the past couple of months alone Ireland has been rocked by two tragic incidents of “Murder Suicide”  in Sligo and Cork, where in each case an older brother has taken the life of their siblings before taking their own life.  So it was quite Ironic that the book group met up in the middle of Suicide Awareness week which ran from the 8th-14 September to discuss this month’s book, The Gamal by Ciaran Collins.

The book tells the story of Sinead and James two talented kids living in the County Cork village of Ballyronan who meet in school when James’s family move back into the area. They quickly develop a friendship strengthened through their love of music and singing and eventually become childhood sweethearts. James is an accomplished pianist and sportsman, while Sinead is a gifted singer, who both dream of escaping their boring rural community for the bright lights of Dublin. However, they are also from different sides of the tracks and are derided by their peers for their talents and dreams when their backs are turned. James is protestant and his family live in a castle on edge of town which been passed down through the family. Sinead is catholic and lives with her abusive alcoholic parents. When James gets accepted into college in Dublin they believe their dreams are about to come true, but Sinead’s dad is diagnosed with cancer and she is guilt tripped into staying at home, while James goes onto Dublin. It’s then that the malicious local young adults, who they thought were friends, start to increase their deviousness. In the end their scheming and narrow-mindedness leads to a rape and a modern Shakespearean tragedy.

The Gamal is the first novel by Cork born writer Ciaran Collins www.ciarancollinsauthor.com, who has written a number of plays before this and is a school teacher in his spare time. The book was published by Bloomsbury www.bloomsbury.com in 2013 and won the Rooney Prize for literature in the same year. The award was set up in 1976 by Dan Rooney the owner of the Pittsburgh Steelers football team and the former US Ambassador to Ireland and is awarded to emerging Irish writers under the age of forty.

ciarancollins

The Gamal in the title is the narrator Charlie McCarthy who is a close friend of both Sinead and James’ as well as someone who feels somewhat instrumental in the final act. He’s rather slow, thus the nickname. Gamal is short for Gamalog, which is Irish for idiot or simpleton, although there are quite a few Irish terms for stupid or slow people.  As the book goes on we discover that Charlie also suffers from PTSD (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder) and that the book is actually a project set by Charlie’s therapist to help him overcome the events of the past five years. The local youths who are the real instigators of the events that occur are also known by nicknames, which are like badges of honour. There’s “Teesh” short Taoiseach – Irish for chief, Dinky, Snoozie, Racey, and The Rascal.  At times it sounds like a modern version of the seven dwarfs. The story highlights the rural and social divisions which still exist in Ireland and what really happens when the devil makes work for idle hands and closed minds.

When I bought the book and thumbed the first few pages I thought it was a self-help book, because at regular intervals the paragraphs have headings. But once you get into this book, the quirky style of the narrative draws you in and holds you, to deliver an enthralling story.

From the very start you realize that the ending isn’t going to be nice, when Charlie describes finding a body under a local bridge and shows you photo’s of the supposed bridge. But Charlie meanders all over the place, really going around the houses in an attempt to tell the whole story. Yes, part of you urges him to just get on with it, but he’s such a loveable rogue, that he really does have you eating out of his hand. But also this comes down to Collins superb plotting.

This book came across as an Irish Adrian Mole, because in all senses it is a diary and its style is all the same even down to the pictures clumsily printed and drawn through out, to help Charlie with his story and please his therapist Dr. Quinn. But also it had remnants of The Butcher Boy by Pat McCabe, owing to the malice that simmers under surface and with the local colloquialisms it drew me back to City of Bohane by Kevin Barry, which you’ll find previously reviewed in this blog.

In Rural Ireland for years there were always really two religions, The Church and GAA, but now that the church is in serious decline, The GAA is the real main stay for the community and life revolves around the local club. Relationships are formed and broken; kids follow their parents and grandparents into the football, hurling, camogie or handball teams. This is depicted beautifully in The Gamal.  The pecking order is decided by strongest player on the pitch, socially he is the alpha male too and god help anyone who upstages him, like James.

But to give it its due this book is a fantastic read, that should be on the reading list of everyone who likes a dark tragicadventures-of-huckleberry-finn__oPt tale told with a large infusion of modern Irish humour and wit. This book had me laughing and smiling all the way through, despite knowing at the back of my mind that it wasn’t going to end well and even when it did, you were still left with a bit of mystery to keep you guessing. Collins has managed to marry the innocence of Huckleberry Finn and dark tragedy of The Field, with the characters and humour of The Quiet Man and the riveting plot of a court room drama.

If this book proves anything, it’s the old adage never trust the quiet ones so if you fancy a dark and well written quirky Irish novel from a talented newcomer then get yourself down to your local bookshop or download a copy ASAP.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

ZEVIN AND FIKRY’S COLLECTED WORK’S PROVES TO BE THE MOST HEARTWARMING AND EMOTIONAL BOOK OF THE YEAR

Standard
Drawing of Original Bray Book Shop

Drawing of original Bray Bookshop

Every town or village needs a humble book shop, a small one off, non chain affiliated outlet where one can browse like you’re in a library and not feel like you’re in a  railway station or airport terminal. Even in the large cities, everyone should seek out a place like this where they can buy a book and also chat to the staff about things they’ve read or where the staff member can recommend books without feeling they’re holding up a queue of irate shoppers. Yes, some of the larger stores are trying to recreate this charm by opening up in-store coffee shops but this just tends to end up being frequented by giggly students on mobiles, latte ladies and business types on laptops which takes away from the quiet, almost monastic feel, of a quaint haven of literature.

When I moved to Bray 36 years ago it had one bookshop in it called The Bray Bookshop, to this day I can remember its racing green front and the large windows on either side of the main door. Inside it was pokey, but still you felt the moment you entered it was a world away from that outside. The counter was up by the door and you were always greeted by the person behind as you entered or left, usually old Mrs Clear or one of her family, even if you didn’t buy anything.  Since then the business has been developed by her daughter and son-in-law, moved to a larger premises on the main street and also grown into Ireland’s largest independent chain of bookstores with 9 stores across the country and a name change to reflect the nationwide coverage, now known as Dubray Books (www.dubraybooks.ie). But the charm hasn’t left the larger premises on Bray main street, it maybe brighter and carry more stock and also do a selection of cards too, but the staff still talk to you like you’re in a two person bookgroup and even on Christmas week one feels like you’ve entered a  monastery bar the constant swish of the double doors at the front. This month’s book is centred around a book shop similar in style and ambience to the original Bray Bookshop, its The Collected Works of A.J. Fikry by Gabrielle Zevin.

Dubray

Dubray Books branch in Bray today

The story centres around the main character A.J Fikry the owner of a book shop on Alice Island, a fictional island off the coast of Massachusetts, loosely based on Nantucket. Life for ‘The Island Book’s owner is in a downward spiral after the death of his wife. Things go from bad to worse when he has a run in with Amelia a single and quirky book rep and then after consuming a bottle of wine one night he is helped into bed by the ghost of his dead wife only to wake up next morning and find the house cleaned and his prized possession a first edition of Tamerlane by Edgar Allan Poe has been stolen. Then a couple of nights later, as he is shutting up shop, he discovers a baby girl called Maya has been left in the book store with acllcted wrks cvr note attached asking him to take care of her. He enlists the help of his sister-in-law, Ismay and her wayward author husband Daniel, as well as the islands police Chief, Lambiase. This , he manages, without very much encouragement, thanks to the bundle of joy that is Maya. How will A.J. cope when Maya has to go into care of Social services? What will become of her? Will A.J. find love again?  Will the book store survive the arrival of a newborn and the winds of change?

Published by Little Brown in March this year, this is New York born Gabrielle Zevin’s (www.gabriellezevin.com) eighth book. More accustomed to writing for young adults, she’s written two books for adults in the past, Magarettown (2005) and The Hole We’re In (2010). Her young adult books include Elsewhere (2005), Memoirs of a Teenage Amnesiac (2007), All These Things I’ve Done (2011), Because It Is My Blood (2012) and In The Age Of Love And Chocolate (2013). Gabrielle is a graduate of Harvard and the screenwriter for the cult hit Conversations With Other Women – starring Helena Bonham Carter, she first got into writing after sending a strongly worded letter to her local paper about a Guns & Roses concert which lead to a job as a music critic.

Stories involving animals and or children tend to bring a lump to my throat, I knew from the moment I saw the cover and read the blurb on the back, that at some stage, I was going to need a tissue. This is a well written story which tugs at the heart strings from the moment Maya makes her entrance, to the emotional ending. Also it had me laughing hysterically at the antics of the main characters and also the support cast of Lambiase, Ismay, Daniel and the various other residents from the island who come to the shop regularly. This book is also  ripe for adaptation as a RomCom, ten to fifteen years ago it would have had Meg Ryan and Tom Hanks names written all over it, nowadays, Hugh Grant maybe with Drew Barrymore again, or Amy Adams and any number of potential leading men.

stried life of AJ FkryThe chapters in the book are named after or at least dedicated to famous books, such as Lamb To The Slaughter and The Bookseller by Dahl as well as The Celebrated Jumping Frog Of Calaveras County by Mark Twain. Which I though strange at first until nearing the end I realised I wasn’t so much reading a story as a list of suggested reading material by Fikry for Maya or even a living will.

 

This has to be one of the best books I’ve read this year and is written by a smart witty young author, who knows how to plot a story and to keep the reader turning the pages right till the end. Even though it was a moving and memorable read to me, maybe to some of it could be seen as a bit sacchariny. There are a couple of plot twists which make you sit up and go wow and made the lower lip wobble slightly, such as the discovery of who Maya’s real dad is and also the depiction of a tragic road accident.

It’s an easy enough read at just over two hundred and forty pages long and closer to a novella then a standard book. This doesn’t take away from a truly satisfying and homely story. The blurb describes it as being a book for those who loved The Guernsey Literary And Potato Peel Pie Society and The Book Thief, while I see it more for those who loved Marley and Me and Secret Life of Bees. What the blurb doesn’t describe is that  the marketing people in the US saw fit to re title it The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry or maybe our marketing guys over here in Europe, thought the title needed to be a bit more high brow.

So there’s not much else to say but get down to your local bookshop and snap up a copy of this book. You won’t have to leave a newborn in the children’s section, just get friendly with a member of staff and leave some hard earned cash on the counter.

Gabrielle Zevin

Gabrielle Zevin

 

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

LUPTON AND SISTER FIND SUCCESS FIRST TIME OUT, WHILE GALLUCCI NEEDS MORE TIME TO FIND HIS FORM.

Standard

sister-rosamund-lupton-ebook-e6e66You’ve got to hand it to the budding novelists of this world; it’s a little easier to get published these days with the advent of kindle and eBooks. You just write the book and it put up on Amazon and see if you can sell any outside of your family and friends or even be discovered by a publishing company. There are still those traditionalists though who get out there and write a couple of chapters and then post or email them round the myriad of publishers and literary agents and await the results of the publishing lottery. Which is awash with reams of confidence sapping rejection letters. Others like the first of this month’s two authors, cut their teeth in other media first.

Rosamund Lupton (www.rosamundlupton.com) was a copywriter and book reviewer, before winning the Carlton Televisions New Writers Competition and being accepted on to BBC’s new writer’s course. In 2010 she had her first book Sister published by Piatkus (www.piatkus.net) since then it’s won awards such Best First Novel at the 2011 Strand Magazine Critics Award as well as the Richard and Judy and WH Smith Readers Choice Award. It’s also been translated into thirty languages.

Sister tells the story of Beatrice an English interior designer now living in New York, whose wayward sister Tess goes missing. Bee jumps on the first plane home and sets about trying find out how and why her sister and soul mate just suddenly disappeared off the face of the earth. The more she discovers about her sister’s personal life the more she realises that despite their weekly Trans-Atlantic phone calls, she didn’t really know her sister that well. With the authorities, her family and Tess’s friends having accepted she’s gone for good, Beatrice throws herself headlong into Tess’s life. Almost taking on her Tess’s persona, by portraying her in a reconstruction and living in her flat. All the while the search for answers takes her on a precarious journey.

Rosamund-Lupton_1910569b

This was my choice for the June meeting of the book group; I first read it back in 2012 and had held it up my sleeve like a sneaky ace for the past year and a half. From the very first page to the very end, the book lives up to the hype on the covers and. It is excellently written and Lupton’s plotting in masterful. She treats the reader like Beatrice’s shadow and you go on an eerie and compelling journey from the get go right to the very end, when she hits you square in the eyes with totally unforeseen ending.

What I remembered from my first time reading it was that I was commuting daily by train from home to work on a journey of about forty five minutes. Some books made the journey drag, but others like this had me stepping on a DART in south county Dublin and what felt like ten minutes later despairingly closing it and having to wait an agonizingly long time to get back to it in the evening.

The other members of the book group also thought this book was brilliantly written and had them finishing it in double quickGONE_GIRL time, while one member who couldn’t make it begged us not to post anything about the ending on social media or emails as she was just finishing it while on a trip abroad and didn’t want us to spoil the ending. It got what I would call in the world of book groups, a standing ovation almost and the last time a book of mine got that was three years ago when I presented them with Room by Emma Donoghue. A few found Beatrice slightly irritating, but loved the plotting and story and also a topic of discussion throughout the meeting was the comparison between Sister and Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl.

The genetics storyline isn’t new but it’s well written and shows some great research, but as she admitted herself in an interview in the back of the book, the medical side was easy due to being married to an obstetrician.  As for advice from Lupton to other first time authors, “Go for it!! And if you meet rejection just keep on it…” she admits she could have papered a small room with rejection letters before getting her first break in scriptwriting. But that’s something she won’t have to worry about from now on. Since publishing Sister her second novel Afterwards was released in 2011.

 

big_img10The other type of first time authors are  the ones that, after the number of rejection letters swamps the whole house, making dinner parties awkward, decide to turn their back on the industry. They go down the self publishing route. My second author this month did a variation on that. He approached Iguana Books, (www.iguanabooks.com) a Canadian publishing company which according to their own website encourages the author to “Pitch In” with covering the cost of getting the book ready for the market, by crowdfunding.  This is the act of seeking small contributions from a group of people, usually over the net.

BP Gallucci (www.bpgallucci.com) is a cat lover and Torontonian born and bred, who’s been writing stories since he was in kindergarten; his first book which was published this year is called Lexus Sam.

The book tells the story of an amnesiac, who calls himself Lexus Sam, but is convinced this isn’t his real name. Currently living in a New York apartment he gets the feeling that he might not be a local because of intermittent flash backs of a life on the West Coast. His apartment is rented out to some guy called Adam Williams and the picture on his drivers licence is the same guy he sees in the mirror every morning, but he thinks it’s all a charade. In his flash backs he also sees a girl called Sarah, so to help him discover who he is he employs the services of a shrink who tries to aid his memory through hypnotic regression, But Lexus questions the doctors motives and as the past merges with the present, he must fight to discover the truth about his past and the mysterious Adam Williams.

If you think the summary above sounds like the marriage of four Matt Damon movies, then you’re not far wrong. Sent to me by Gallucci after we hooked up on Twitter,  the book its self feels like the reworking of more then just a couple of movies, a whole video store worth to be exact. There is no beginning of sorts you are just thrown into the story and mostly I found myself flailing to find direction.

I’m all for getting the reader into the story but you must allow them to get a feeling of where it might be going.Unless it’s set in a life raft, but even then, you  imagine an island, finding a flare gun, even the hint of an engine in the distance. This book just seemed to be occupied by a series of random stereotypical characters and some vague well worn plot. Halfway through, I couldn’t give a damn if he never got his memory back, hey he has an apartment, money to buy pizzas… life’s good.

First time books are rarely instant bestsellers, but it’s like passing your driving test, some do it first time others on their second, third for fourth go . Look at Dan Brown for example it was only after The Da Vinci Code  his fourth book was a bestseller that Digital Fortress, Angels & Demons and Deception Point start making money. Even before that he wrote a number of clunky humorous self help books, one under the pseudonym Dannielle Brown and the other under his wife’s name. Also it took John Le Carre three books to find international acclaim with The Spy Who Came In From The Cold.

BP Gallucci

So, I’m not knocking Gallucci’s ability(especially not a bloke with all those “tats”), just the fact that this first attempt at writing a compelling piece of fiction needs a bit of work. Which I’m sure he will do and who knows down the line, he’ll be up there with the best of them.

So if you want a good summer read get up close with Sister and leave the lost boy where you found him.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

TWAN ENG’S AWARD WINNING HISTORICAL NOVEL GETS BOGGED DOWN IN THE GARDEN

Standard

garden of evening mists cvrRecords estimate somewhere between 3 and 10 million people of various nationalities lost their lives in Japanese prisoner of war camps between 1937 and the end of the Second World War. If you thought the Nazi’s had the market cornered in the mistreatment of POWS, then you were wrong.  The Japanese were equally brutal, if not far more depraved. They  worked their charges literally to death, by getting their prisoners to work in mines, fields, shipyards and factories on a diet of about 600 calories a day and in extreme heat as well as  mosquito and disease ridden conditions.

The worst conditions were those experienced by POW’s forced to build the Burma-Thailand railway. Prisoners of war and Asian labourers worked side by side to build the 260 mile railroad by hand. They were expected to work from dawn to dusk, moving earth, building bridges, blasting through mountains and laying track.

With the 70th anniversary of D-Day having just past, the The-Railway-Manexperiences of those prisoners have all but been over shadowed and forgotten, except for maybe re runs of the 1980’s BBC Drama Tenko and last years Critically acclaimed movie The Railwayman starring Colin Firth and Nicole Kidman, and books like this months book group read The Garden of the Evening Mists by Tan Twan Eng.

The book tells the story of a Yung Ling a retired Malaysian judge who is a survivor of the Japanese POW camps.On her retirement she seeks solace in the Malayan foot hills where she plans to build a memorial Japanese garden to her sister who didn’t survive the camps. She needs some help and is pointed in the direction of the Garden of the Evening Mists and its creator Arimoto, once the gardener for the Emperor of Japan and a man who possess extraordinary horticultural skill. She accepts his offer to take up an apprenticeship under him, thus beginning a journey that bring her past and present together.

This is Penang born Twan Eng’s second book, his first was The Gift of Rain and was published 2007, it was long listed for the Man Booker Prize. The Garden Of Evening Mists published in 2012 was shortlisted for the 2012 Man Booker prize  and won the Man Asian Literary Prize 2012 as well as the 2013 Walter Scott Prize for historical fiction. He worked as a solicitor in a Kuala Lumpur law firm before becoming a full time writer; he’s a martial arts expert who divides his time between Cape Town and Kuala Lumpur.

Tan_Twan_EngEverybody has a minimum page rule, after which if the story hasn’t grabbed you by then, it’s time to put the book down because life’s too short. For me it’s fifty to one hundred. I gave this book one hundred and ten pages, and with only three hundred fifty in the whole book that’s very generous. Take into account the fact I had two three hour windows when I had nothing else to do but read it owing to travelling on a ferry back and forth across the Irish Sea. This book still failed to hook me and that’s alright because nobody’s going to like every book they read.

The other members of the book group all agreed that the first third of the book is slow but after that it warms up and delivers a nice story. But for me I had better things to do, like watch seagulls, other ferries and white horses or enjoy a complimentary massage, yes they actually have that on certain ferry crossings on the Irish Sea.

My partner said I shouldn’t post a review because I didn’t finish the book, but I recently read a restaurant review by Tom Doorley of the Irish Daily Mail where he went to one restaurant in Dublin and left after waiting forty minutes to be served and only getting water and bread. He still wrote his review, hence why I have one here.

caution_slow_moving_vehicle_sticker

I’m not saying you shouldn’t try this book, but if you do. You have been warned, the start needs a lot of patience. Rather like the Heron on the front cover. Better still, get your hands on  a copy of The Railwayman.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

HARRIS AND PIQUART DELIVER A TOUR DE FORCE FOR “DREYFUSARDS”

Standard

Harris-Officer-Spy CvrHistory is littered with cases of miscarriages of justice from around the world that have shaken society to its core and attracted the attention of the world media. America has examples such as the Salem Witch Trials which led to the deaths of 19 innocent people on suspicion of Witchcraft, while the 1954 Dr. Sam Shepherd case is believed to have inspired the TV series and movie “The Fugitive”.  Britain has its fair share  although quite a few are related to the “Troubles” in Northern Ireland,  The Birmingham Six (1975), Judith Ward (1974),The Guildford Four (1974) and Maguire seven (1976).

It’s to France we go for this month’s book, a country not immune from miscarriages of justice and scandal. Joan of Arc was burned at the stake in 1431 on charges of Heresy but she was posthumously cleared in 1456. However, it’s the other big historical miscarriage of justice, The Dreyfus affair which forms the basis for the Robert Harris book “An Officer and a Spy”.

The Dreyfus affair was a political scandal which divided France from 1894 till 1906. It started with the court-martial of a Jewish

Alfred Dreyfusofficer Alfred Dreyfus on charges of treason and passing secrets to a foreign nation (Germany). He was found guilty in 1894 and sentenced to life imprisonment at the penal colony of Devils Island in French Guiana. He spent five years there in ever worsening and inhumane conditions imposed on him by a government desperate to rid him from the memory of its people. During that time evidence came to light that the actual culprit was one Major Esterhazy. The book tells the story through the eyes of Major Georges Piquart, the officer who actually first discovered that there were problems with the evidence. The evidence in question based solely on a couple of telegrams retrieved from the waste paper basket in the German embassy.

A career soldier, Piquart finds himself up against a very Georges Piquartdetermined foe in the French army and it’s Statistics Section (The Secret service) of which he is the head. As is usual in the clandestine world, there are no real friends and everyone is out to look after themselves. From the moment he is appointed head of the Secret Service he knows he is an outsider and that the staff under his command resent him. The more he pursues the truth and aims to prove Dreyfus’ innocence the more the government and its long tentacles of power attempt to deter him, even threatening his life and those of his family and loved ones.

I was first introduced to the case in history class in school, through my teacher Mr. Walsh; where the real hero was the eminent French journalist Emil Zola and his cabal of “Dreyfusards”. According to the history lessons and the schools books, Piquart plays a mere supporting role.  The thing about Irish schooling is that European history is widely covered. While my partner who was educated in England had never heard of the Dreyfus affair before she read this book.

Before this I’d never read a Robert Harris book, I’d seen the film “The Ghost Writer” an adaptation of his book “The Ghost” with Ewan McGregor, Pierce Brosnan and Kim Cattrall and after seeing it, was kicking myself for not reading the book before hand. This is Harris’s ninth book of fiction which includes the afore mentioned The Ghost plus Fatherland, Enigma, Archangel, Pompeii, Imperium, Lustrum and The Fear Index. He’s written five books of non-fiction on subjects such as Hitler, Neil Kinnock, the media and the Falkland’s crisis and co – authored a book on the history of chemical and biological warfare with  BBC current affairs presenter Jeremy Paxman. Harris is married to the author Gill Hornby , the sister of Nick Hornby.

harriswebnew2_2683845b

 

When it was initially recommended for the book group, even the chooser had some slight reservation about its length and suitability for a book group read. There are no real hard and fast rules about books for book groups, each to there own. But it has to be practical to be able to read the book in the time between meetings most groups meet month to month although some may make it shorter due to being made up solely of housewives or retired members, who might have a bit more time on their hands. Although that said, I respect that housewives lead very busy lives too and are not spending their days sipping latté’s, watching daytime TV and reading.

One of the group, bought the audio version, due to difficulties in sourcing a copy (I can assure you it is quite widely available) and said it was the best way to read it as the narrator David Rintoul really brought it to life with his pronunciation of the French names and place names.

An Officer and a Spy takes a long drawn out piece of French history and turns it into an engrossing page turner. Another member of the group read it over the Easter weekend just gone, that’s almost 500 pages in four days. Personally, I had the book finished with a week to spare before book group. Evidence, if it was needed, that this book really hooks the reader from the first page to the four hundred and seventy ninth with its gripping narrative, cast of well drawn characters and tension filled story-line.

In the past I’ve often berated books for being over crowded with characters, but in this book, Harris’s skilled penmanship makes sure that they don’t detract from the story-line and the role of the main character Piquart. It takes a certain skill to make a piece of history tantalizing and Harris is a master at this having done it numerous times before, for example creating an alternative ending to the Second World War as a basis for a detective novel in Fatherland. Similarly Pompeii is used as the setting of  a thriller set days before the eruption, Enigma is set around the code breakers of Bletchley in WWII and Archangel a mystery around the death of Stalin and his apparent heir.

Just researching these other titles for this piece has me salivating Fear Indexover them. Only the other day I discovered a friend had given me a copy of Harris’s 2011 book The Fear Index. This will definitely be moved up the bedside locker TBR pile and may even accompany me on a weeks hiking in the Derbyshire Peak District later this year.

They say the past is another country; it may be set in another country in this book. But Harris makes it very real and one of the best history lessons I’ve had in a while, sorry Mr. Walsh. So take my advice, hop on your bike and pedal to the shops for a copy of this book, some croissants and French roast coffee. Then lock the door, dig out your favourite beret and settle in for an amazing read that will leave you breathless even before the Tour De France starts.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

JONASSON’S OAP ADVENTURE STORY IS OVERWORKED AND NEEDS A ZIMMER FRAME FOR THE READER.

Standard

The longest place name in the world with 85 letters is Taumata­whakatangihanga­koauau­o­tamatea­turi­g  pukakapiki­maunga­horo­nuku­pokai­whenua­kitanatahu. It’s a town on the north island of

World-Oldest-Place-Name-221077New Zealand and means “The summit where Tamatea, the man with the big knees, the climber of mountains, the land-swallower who travelled about, played his flute to his loved one”. The longest place name in Europe is a Welsh town on the island of Anglesea called, Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch with 58 letters, which means  “Saint Mary’s church in a hollow of white hazel near the swirling whirlpool of the church of Saint Tysilio with a red cave” (just imagine trying to get a taxi to there after a few drinks).

There’s no listing for the longest place name in Sweden, but owing to Swedish grammar they have some infinite words and the longest one is Spårvagnsaktiebolagsskensmutsskjutarefackföreningspersonalbeklädnadsmagasinsförrådsförvaltarens, which at 95 letters means “The manager of the depot for the supply of uniforms to the personnel of the track cleaner’s union of the tramway companies”. (I’d love to see the sign on his office door)

There are quite a few books with very long titles; the longest ever isbook-cover-100-year-old-man a book by Nigel Tomms which has over 3999 characters and 370 words. A list compiled by members of the website www.goodreads.com  a couple of years ago listed 491 wordy titles, but this months book wasn’t  on it, due to being unpublished. It has 13 words in the title and is ‘The Hundred year Old man who Climbed Out of the Window and Disappeared’, by Jonas Jonasson.

The book tells the story of Allan Karlsson a centenarian who only minutes before attending a one hundred birthday party in his honour, decides on a whim to climb out the window of the nursing home where he resides and go for a walk. Thus starts a big adventure, in which, Allan steals a case full of drug money and befriends a gaggle of weird and wonderful human companions with whom he divides the 50 Million Swedish Kronor. There’s also an Elephant in tow. Allan’s disappearance sparks a nationwide man hunt lead by a lonely Police Inspector and members of the drug gang intent on reclaiming their loot. Soon the police are inundated with tips and misleading leads, not to mention the bodies of two of the drug gang. But innocent old Allan isn’t unused to being the centre of attention, because at regular intervals we revisit Allan’s early life, in which he seems to have been at every major political event and dined with every major political leader over the past century from Mao Se Tung to Stalin, Truman and Kim Jung Il . He also discovered how to create the Atom Bomb and gave nuclear secrets to the Russians quite by chance. All while in the company of Albert Einstein’s younger and slower brother, Herbert. But in the present day the rag tag group seem to just about remain one step a head of their pursuers, but for how much longer? And when they are caught what will happen to them?

Jonas-Jonasson-2-

This is Swedish journalist Jonas Jonasson’s first of two books which was published in 2009 but then translated into English in 2012 and has since been converted into another 29 languages. His second book was originally called the “The Analphabet who knew How to count”, but has recently been changed for the American market into “The Orphan who saved the king of Sweden”. Jeez, here we go again, dumbing things down for middle America. Couldn’t they just call it “The Illiterate Who Could Count”? Middle America is not that backward that they don’t know what the word “illiterate” means and anyone there who doesn’t know that, will not be found in a bookshop or a library. The hundred year old man has since been made into a movie, with subtitles, how long I wonder before there’s an US backed English language version? Time will tell.

This book is supposed to be rip roaring yarn, or a “… laugh out loud best seller…” according to The Telegraph, the Irish Times says it should carry a health warning for those irritated by helpless chortling. Wrong! It’s funny, but nowhere did it have me bent double with pains of laughter. It’s more a series highs and lows, at first the premise of an OAP climbing out of his nursing home window and wandering off is promising, the first half of the book Is humorous, and had me smiling and chuckling, but from midway its a chore to carry on, the story telling feels laboured and that Jonasson is trying too hard to make light of everything. The supposedly funny events are not memorable. Hence, it is nowhere near the likes of James Herriot’s and the recently deceased Sue Townsend’s books. Now those are funny books, especially Sue’s early work with Adrian Mole.

I found that Jonasson has tried to fit too much into one book, this book is 389 pages long! It’s a regular gripe at the book group, that there is little or no  input by a half decent editor these days, using a big read biro or scissors. This is clearly in evidence here. Trying to run two very intricate stories side by side through a book like this never works and ends up distracting the reader, it’s like watching two siblings vie for your attention. The stories from Allan’s early life come across more as a set of sketches, which could have been their own book, with a bit more work, but Jonasson and his lazy editorial team have fallen down on the job badly.

As for the characters, there’s too many of them, even with their unusual names, such as the henchmen “Bucket” and “Bolt”, then there’s their Boss. Called The Boss, whose real name is  Per Gunnar Gerdin, he’s referred to by both monikers in the book. Of the rag-tag bunch of friends Allan picks up, Sonya the elephant sticks out, then her surrogate owner “The Beauty” we do find out her name but  I forget it now. There’s an immigrant hotdog seller who’s a ‘jack of all trades’, another  uninspiring character whose name  I forget  and his estranged brother. Not to mention the police inspector, the prosecutor and that’s just in the current story, there’s loads more in the autobiographical story. As for Allan, he’s believable to a point, but he comes across as a Swedish version of Damien from the The Omen, as almost everyone who comers into contact him with meets their maker shortly after they part company.

As for the inclusion of the historical world leaders, it feels like a literary attempt at product placement. At first, it’s funny to have Allan having dinner with Trueman on the night Woodrow Wilson dies, and then Stalin, but  by the time you get to Kim Jung IL and Churchill it’s parody gone mad.

I hate coming down on books and before I come across as  being very clinical and overly judgmental about The Hundred Year Old Man, there is another reason why this didn’t work for me. Overall the book group was split on likes and dislikes, but one theory I expressed was that people have very different tastes in comedy. What central Europeans and Scandinavian’s find hilariously funny is not what us Celts may find funny. How many Europeans find the likes of Father Ted, Fawlty Towers and Allo Allo, hilarious? It’s the same thing with many of Europe’s home produced comedy programmes (Not that we see many) The crime fiction genre is a different kettle of fish and is proven by the success of the Millennium trilogy, by Stig Larsson, Jo Nesbo’s books and the TV series Borgen. So one has to ask, is the reason I feel this didn’t work also down to things being lost in translation? Comedy doesn’t translate across as easily as crime.

I discovered two things while researching this article, firstly that fifty million Kroner is actually worth very little outside Sweden, according to www.xe.com it’s almost five and a half million euro, seven and a half million dollars or four and a half million pounds sterling. That’s one of the few things that made me laugh, the thought that if they crossed a border or somehow got on a plane the case of money Allan was dividing equally among his cohorts would devalue rather rapidly.

the-little-old-lady-who-broke-all-the-rules-978144725061601Secondly is that an almost exact replica of this story has been published in Sweden in 2012 and since translated in to English, by the same translator. It’s “The Little Old Lady Who Broke All the Rules” by Catharina Ingelman Sundberg. Basically, it’s about a 79 year old who plans to break out of her nursing home with a group of her fellow residents, to run riot, rob banks and get up to all sorts of mischief. It begs the question, don’t they do originality in Sweden? Is it just a fluke or did Ingelman’s publishers not read Jonasson’s book?

So, if you’re looking for an unchallenging moderately funny book to while a way a beach holiday, this may be your cup of tea but if it’s a commuter read that you’ll pick up in the morning and evening on your way to and from work this is to be avoided. The numerous characters and stories will have you wondering where the hell you are.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

NO LONELY PLANET FOR CITY OF BOHANE, BUT AN EXCELLENT JOURNEY TO THE DARKSIDE.

Standard

city-of-bohane-orangeThere’s a new doctor in the house. No, I’m perfectly fine. It’s a Sci-Fi reference and if you’re still lost I’m talking about the recent appointment of Peter Capaldi as the new doctor in the long running BBC drama Doctor Who. If the 12th  Doc’ was to open the door of the TARDIS in the next series and find himself in the setting for this month’s book, then it would be a very interesting episode indeed. The book is City of Bohane by Kevin Barry.

The story is set in the fictional city of Bohane on the west coast of Ireland (pronounced Bo-Haan, I’m reliably informed by other members of the book group). It’s a seedy, malevolent place where life is cheap and sex and drugs are what fuels its economy. Control of the different parts of the city and the profits from its illicit trade are run by various gangs, the largest being the Hartnett fancy gang and their leader Logan Hartnett. A number of rival gangs from the other side of the city are itching to get their hands on his business so it looks like the tenuous peace of the city is about to be shattered, as well as that Hartnett’s old nemesis  Gant Broderick has returned to the city after a twenty five year absence. He has unfinished business with Hartnett’s wife Macu but is that all? What of the younger members of the gang? Is Logan facing trouble from within his own ranks? Will life and the balance of power ever be the same in the once great metropolis of Bohane?

kevin Barry

 

This is Limerick born writer Kevin Barry’s first novel, he’s previously written two collections of short stories ‘There Are Little Kingdoms’ in 2007 and ‘Dark Lies the Island’ in 2012.  The book won the 2013 Dublin IMPAC literary award and it is the first time I have had cause to actually agree with the judges on their choice. Usually it’s the shortlisted runners up that I’ve thought were more deserving of the top spot. IMPAC is far from the world’s best known literary prize, but it is growing in recognition and stature behind its all conquering neighbour in the UK, the Man Booker. Thanks in part to it having the largest prize in the world of €100,000.

This maybe very different from any Irish book I’ve read before but its now one of the best. Firstly, Bohane itself is a mishmash of various other cities both fictional and real. It’s like Barry took Gotham, New York, Dublin and Paris then stitched them all together. This is not surprising as he lived in seventeen different places before he was thirty six years old, including Cork, Santa Barbara and Barcelona.  Bohane does seem to be set in an alternate universe, where there are no cars and very few pieces of technology like phones or TV’s but they have trucks and an ‘EL’ train. No guns either, all the fighting is done by hand or with knives.

One of the nicest things about the book is the language, its fruity to say the least and quite knackery. At first it’s hard to imagine where in Ireland you are, sometimes inner-city Dublin other times the west of Ireland. Phrases like “Sweet Baba Jay” when taking the lords name in vain reminded me of Hill Street Blues Lt. Hunter, who often exclaimed “Judas Priest!!!” or “Judas H, Christmas!!!” The down side to the rich flowery dialect is that it often slows the reader down as you try to translate what the characters are saying but don’t let that take anything from a warming and descriptive element of the book. It’s not surprising that this book wasn’t nominated by libraries from outside of Ireland for IMPAC, as with the release of the film The Commitments in the US, readers not acquainted or related with the Emerald Isle might require a small list of translations to help them on their journey through Bohane.

The book shows the influence of films such as Blade Runner and Sin City, owing to the very sepia styled imagery and gothic themes running through it. Also the Mad Max movie Beyond the Thunderdome came across to me as inspiration for one tribe WillyWonkacalled the “Sand Pikey’s” who live in the dunes outside the city. Meanwhile the whole gang rivalry storyline is rather weak and seems like a bad episode of the internationally acclaimed RTE hit ‘Love Hate’. However, it is emboldened by the vivid descriptions of the settings and the myriad of weird and wonderful characters, like the local paper Editor Dom Gleeson, his hunched back photographer, Mary Grimes and Logan’s two henchmen, Wolfie Stanners and Fucker Burke, while Hartnett comes across as a rather dandy character who dresses like Willy Wonka.

If this book was ever to be developed into a visual format, I could see it as a graphic novel initially. But you only have to see that graphic novels and darkly drawn comic heroes have an excellent track record in crossing over to the big screen. In an interview in 2012 Barry confirmed the book had been optioned and that he’s written a first draft of a script.

So take my advice, forget about packing your copy of lonely planet. put on your best Pikey or Oirish accent, along with a decent pair of knuckle dusters and prepare for a very enjoyable trip into the shadowy environs of Bohane.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

FITZGERALD’S ICONIC PIECE FALLS SHORT OF GATSBY’S GREAT EGO AND PARTIES IN SIZE AND SUBSTANCE.

Standard

great-gatsby-penguin-modern-classicsWhen was the last time you sat in a public place, like a train station, bus stop or cafe and passed the time waiting for someone or just enjoying the ambience, by people watching and playing the game “Guess-What they do?”, we humans are a naturally inquisitive bunch. While most people leave the guessing to their imagination, some people take the game too far, to pique their curiosity and verge on the practice of stalking, by following the subject down the street just to see if they go into an accountant’s office, or a car repair workshop. In the literary world there are numerous examples of people with mysterious or non-existent backgrounds for one reason or another, some are prime examples of bad writing whereby the characters haven’t been flushed out fully or it is a plot device; in this months book it forms an integral part of the story. The book in question is F. Scott Fitzgerald’s – “The Great Gatsby”.

The Great Gatsby tells the story of Nick Carroway a bond salesman in 1920’s New York, who lives in Long Island. He discovers by chance, that his neighbour is a flamboyant socialite known for his large opulent house parties that take place every weekend. The host is Mr. Jay Gatsby, who gives off the outward appearance of an enigmatic individual, who has lived a life less ordinary but in reality is a rather reserved, lonesome and mysterious figure. When Nick is suddenly summoned by Gatsby to one of his parties, he meets the hoi polloi of American high society. Most are invited, while there are quite a few who are there just because they’ve followed the crowd. Whilst nobody knows much about the man at the centre; they all have their own opinions and help the rumour mill as to where their host is from or what he did in the past. Nick and Gatsby become friends of sorts as his curiosity as to who the real Gatsby is gets the better of him. Their summer long friendship takes Nick on a heady journey through the sordid and often hedonistic lives of the well to do in America at the beginning of the roaring twenties but, as with most lives led this way, there are casualties and this is where things start to unravel. Can their friendship, Gatsby’s enigmatic persona and the lives of those around him survive the repercussions?

The-Great-Gatsby1

What makes a book a classic, does it have to have made it on to the school curriculum? Does it have to have had a number of screen adaptations? Or is it longevity? It’s hard to tell, if you haven’t seen either of the screen adaptations the most recent starring Leonardo Di Caprio, then that’s good, because you can now read this book and then compare all three.

Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald was an American writer of five novels, This Side of Paradise, The Beautiful and the Damned, The Great Gatsby, Tender is The Night and The Love of the Last Tycoon. He also wrote ten collections of short stories, which included among them The Curious Case of Benjamin Button; published in the collection Tales of the Jazz Age. The Fitzgerald’sfscottfitzgerald & family had one child a daughter called, very imaginatively Frances Scott Fitzgerald, who went on to become a writer and journalist too. His relationship and life with his wife Zelda mirrored that of the lifestyle of those in the Great Gatsby. It is claimed that Hemingway believed Zelda was forcing Fitzgerald to drink in order to distract him from his writing. As well as that, Fitzgerald’s short 44 years on this earth were regularly overshadowed by financial woes as a result of the couples taste for the good life.

What of the book its self? Well the characters are rather shallow and one dimensional, Nick is a lowly bond trader in the city, who just manages to somehow get enough money to live on Long Island. Gatsby’s house is a large rambling pile with servants; a pool etc, while nothing at all is mentioned about Nick’s home. Is it a three bed cottage?  Does he have servants? As for the other notable characters, such as Nick’s cousin, Daisy Buchanan and her husband Tom: they live in a large house with servants on the other side of the bay, directly across from Gatsby’s and Nick’s. The main crux of the story is unfinished business between Daisy and Gatsby. Tom is a typical college footballer, straight out of Ivy League who again does something in the city (What, we’re never really told), but bar that his main pursuit in life is carrying on with a mistress behind Daisy’s back. The only other main character is that of Jordan Baker, a professional female golfer (something of a rarity back then), who has an on-off relationship with Nick. If you can call it that.

mia-farrow-robert-redford-the-great-gatsby-coverIf  I was to take anything from the book it’s that it could easily have been set in the modern world where we are still, if not even more, fascinated with being the centre of attention and everyone wants to be an over night celebrity. But just like Gatsby, when we do get to be the centre of attention, can you really keep up? As with the spate of recent “Neknominations”, trying to be the next big thing can have tragic consequences.  The book is also very short at 165 pages in length, calling it a novella is being generous; I’ve read longer instruction manuals. But this is not surprising as Fitzgerald was more accustomed to short story writing. God help him if he’d had to write a modern day book which average out at 350 pages.

So take my advice, unless it’s on your bucket list avoid this bland little yarn and watch either version of the film adaptations instead.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

THE PEOPLE OF THE BOOK IS A GRIPPING HISTORICAL THRILLER, BUT NEEDS ANOTHER COUPLE OF INSTALLMENTS TO THREATEN DAN BROWN AND LANGDON

Standard

People of the bookDo you know what a Haggadah is? Neither did I till Christmas. It’s a Jewish Passover prayer book, usually owned by individual families. Even a friend of mine whose mum is Jewish, but is a lapsed practitioner  and whose extended family are of the Jewish faith, admitted he had to Google it when I asked him recently by way of research for this article.

All across the globe and down through history there have been historic literary works which contain ornate and intricate paintings and stylized text and other various illuminated manuscripts. In Ireland we have the Book of Kells, England has the Magna Carta. The majority of the world’s religions have had numerous illuminated manuscripts such as the Book of Hours for devout Catholics, the Hebrew Seder Keri’ath Shema Al ha-Mitha (prays before retiring at night), the Jewish Torah and the Koran of Islam. Many of these magnificent works have also been lost as a result war and religious persecution. This month’s book group choice was a novel about BookOfKells3one such book and was selected by our founder Kathleen (who bears an uncanny resemblance to author Sophie Hannah -see previous review). Her choice was the Geraldine Brooks novel The People Of The Book.

The People Of The Book tells the story Dr Hana Heath an Australian book conservator who is summoned by the UN to Sarajevo in the spring of 1996 to trace the history of an ancient Jewish Haggadah found in the basement of the battle scarred national museum. It’s only a matter of months after the ending of the civil war and the city is still quiet tense while also trying to return to some semblance of normality, without the fear of death by sniper. On opening the book Hana finds among its pages things like a butterfly wing, sea salt, wine and blood stains and a white hair. What seem like totally random and ordinary everyday things you might find in an old manuscript, are to Hana’s trained eye, huge clues as to how the book found its way to Sarajevo and also where it came from originally. In the resulting narratives we are transported back in time to Sarajevo in the midst of the second World War,  to a very promiscuous Vienna in the 1800’s, to  16th century Venice during the inquisitions and  to Spain in the late fourteen hundreds.

As she nears the end of her voyage of discovery, which, in real time takes her back and fourth across the Atlantic and Europe while also answering questions about her own past, as well as explaining  the reason for the dysfunctional nature of her relationship with her mum. Hana discovers a sinister plot to destroy this book, which almost costs her, her career. Will she finally discover the truth about this mysterious book and stop it falling into the wrong hands.

Ten years ago very few people knew what a symbologist was or did; now, thanks to Dan Brown, Tom Hanks, four blockbusting books and two hugely successful films, more and more students are considering symbology as a career (actually its Typography or religious Iconology).  The same may now be said for book conservation following this book. From the first page the book feels like an imitation of a Dan Brown novel. But Brooks doesn’t imitate, she and Dr. Hana Heath go out and say “Oih! Robert Langdon, move over there’s a new girl in town”. It’s currently a one off piece and hopefully this won’t be, as Hana is a great character. She’s likable and different; her attitude to sex and relationships is easy going to say the least, not what you might expect from someone in her line of work (although neither is Robert Langdon and his Mickey Mouse watch). She seems to have an ex in every country and the back story involving the all but non-existent  relationship with her mum is solid and makes her character believable.

angels-and-demons-robert-langdon

The book is engrossing and informative from the get go, if you aren’t too familiar with Jewish history, this is a fantastic way to get acquainted with it and ancient Europe. Even when it jumps back in time to tell the individual stories behind the clues Hana finds in the Haggadah, each short story grabs you and drags you into its own little world. Whether you’re reading about a Venetian Rabbi feeding his gambling habit with a charitable donation he got to help the poor in the ghetto  or a young Jewish girl trying to outrun the inquisition in Spain. Before returning the reader back to Hana and the modern day story, which equally holds you.

sarajevo haggadhThe novel was inspired by the events surrounding the real Sarajevo Haggadah which was thought to have been lost during the civil war but was discovered following a break in at the national museum near the end of the war. It was restored using UN funding and now is on permanent display in Sarajevo.

Published in 2008, this isn’t the Australian born, former war correspondent’s first book of fiction, but her third of four. Her other books include, Year of Wonders (2001), March (2005) for which she won the Pulitzer Prize for fiction in 2006 and finally Caleb’s Crossing (2011). She’s also written two non-fiction books, Nine Parts Desire(1995) and Foreign Correspondence(1997).

I sincerely hope some film director or producer decides to turn thisbrooks_dock_col book into a movie because it would do equally as well as Angels and Demons or The Da Vinci Code. I could easily see Toni Collette as Hana.  So take my advice, if you liked Robert Langdon’s escapades you’ll enjoy this and even if you didn’t you’ll still  love this original take on the work of a book conservationist. So get down to your local bookshop and snap up a copy of The People Of The Book.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

HANNAH AND HER ORPHAN CHOIR SHOULD REMAIN UNSEEN AND HEARD MORE AS THEY SING TOTALLY OFF THE HORROR KEY TO SUCCESS.

Standard

orphn choirDo you believe in ghosts? Have you ever seen one? What about noisy neighbours? The most famous ghost story ever told is set around this time of year. As for my experiences with them, yes I believe in them. Thanks to a rather chilling night in Wicklow’s historic gaol (www.wicklowshistoricgaol.com), south of Dublin and the numerous unexplained stuff featured on Pick TV’s “Most Haunted”.  As for the noise from next-door, no, we just have thin walls my neighbours would wholeheartedly agree. So what does this have to do with this month’s book, it’s The Orphan Choir by Sophie Hannah.

Sophie Hannah is a British Novelist and Poet; she has previously s_Sophie-Hannahwritten eight psychological thrillers featuring her characters Simon Waterhouse and Charlie Zailer, the most recent being The Carrier (2013). They have  been adapted for TV as the series “Case Sensitive” starring Olivia Williams and Darren Boyd. She’s also written two children’s books and this one horror novella also published in 2013.

The Orphan Choir tells the story of Louise Beeston, a mother of one, whose gifted son Joseph is forced to board at a school in Cambridge so he can sing in the schools elite boys’ choir. She doesn’t like this, believing he’s being detained against his will by his choir master but has gone along with her husband’s wishes for the betterment of her son’s education. Then her neighbour Justin or Mr Fahrenheit as she refers to him, who  smokes hash and drinks with his fellow delinquent friends, starts playing loud music at all hours of the night at full volume. She complains to the council but to no avail, then she starts to hear not Just “Queen” being played in the wee small hours, but choral music sung by young children. She suspects Mr. Fahrenheit is tormenting her.   When the opportunity comes up to move to a private estate in the Cambridgeshire countryside, fearing for her sanity, she jumps at the chance but the choral music doesn’t stop. Louise must find out how Mr. Fahrenheit is managing to get to her this far out of town – or is he responsible?

This is the best time of year to read spooky books, well not just Christmas time, but winter in general. When the nights have closed in and the wind is howling around the rafters. The cover of the book really catches your attention, so does the title. It suggests all manner of things and my mind was racing away at thoughts of what might lie beyond the covers. Alas the book is a let down in certain aspects. Yes it tells a good story and the idea was a good one but it comes across as more like  the demented ravings of a menopausal woman than someone haunted by the sounds of an unseen choir of children.

cropped-choristers-IMG_9666CC

Near the end there are a couple of nice twists and the liturgical responses which pop up through out the story, because they are being sung by the choir would probably add something to the piece if  I could sing or even hum them to get a feel for it or if I’d had the time to hunt the music out and have it playing in the background while reading. This only confirmed my suspicions that unless you are familiar with the music featured in the book, it would only really get the hair standing on the back your head if it was adapted for radio. But apart from that it falls short of the first rule of horror writing… Scare them.

So over the remaining months and weeks of winter, if you’re searching for something to have you looking over your shoulder, and flinching at every little sound on those dark cold evenings, this book isn’t it. Me, I’d worry about the credit card bill that’s coming in a couple of week’s time, that’s the scariest thing, this side of Christmas.

______________________________________

Let me take this opportunity to thank all those of you who have started to follow The Library Door and through the various social media made others aware of it’s existence. May you have a happy new year and enjoy reading all my future reviews from beyond The Library Door.  Adrian

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨